FANDOM


  • Can Category:Jeff the Killer and Category:Jane the Killer be added together if both appear in the same story? I'm asking because Jane is a subcategory of Jeff, even though they are (TECHNICALLY) separate characters. I was thinking that, rather than Jane being a subcategory of Jeff, they could be basically two halves of the same whole category, with the "Jeff-Inspired" category being a subcategory of both (read: cannot be added on a page categorized as either Jeff or Jane).

    Also, for stories where both characters appear (specifically stories where Jeff fights Jane), I was thinking of making a category called "Jeff vs. Jane" (which neither "Jeff the Killer" or "Jane the Killer" could be added to). Another category I would like to propose, which "Jeff vs. Jane" would be a subcategory, is "Battles" (or "X vs. X", or something of the like).

    Actually, since Jane is a spinoff of Jeff, I feel we should keep it as a subcategory of Jeff the Killer, but still treat it as more or less its "twin category" (*COUGH*JanetheRecolor*COUGH*).

    What do you think?


      Loading editor
    • Hm, this is a tricky question. Jane usually fights Jeff in stories she's in, doesn't she?

        Loading editor
    • Hmm... Alright, how about we keep Jane the Killer as a subcategory of Jeff the Killer and only put stories about or involving Jeff that DON'T have anything to do with Jane in the Jeff the Killer category?

      We could create a "Versus" category (I decided that was the best name for it) for pastas about two or more spinoff characters engaged in some kind of fight/conflict and make "Jane the Killer" a subcategory of it.

      Baring in mind the possibility of a Jane story that does NOT involve her fighting Jeff, we could include in the category description "Almost always overlaps with both "Versus" and "Jeff the Killer", but not always."

        Loading editor
    • That sounds reasonable. I guess The Worm In Paradise would count as a "Versus" story too, as it's basically Worm Jeff vs. Slenderman.

        Loading editor
    • So pastas involving both would only have the "Jane" category?

        Loading editor
    • I think they should be seperate,

        Loading editor
    • How about a we call it "Jeff and Jane" If there in it and keep jane as a subcatagory

        Loading editor
    • I say keep 'em separate. Jane does actually have a few pastas where she never interacts with Jeff at all. 'course, those pastas were written by a person with a canine-based username who's been banned from the Creepypasta Wiki, so they'll probably never see the light of day on any pasta wiki... *shrug*

      Just my two cents.

      The Red Grandmaster (talk) 03:10, March 26, 2013 (UTC)

        Loading editor
    • Keep them separate for the story to be less cheesy

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.