FANDOM


  • So I was looking around in Suggested Reading, and I realized something; it seems like some of the stories there aren't that well written. Now, the SR has been the same for quite a bit. So, I figure, maybe we should take a look around and see what does and doesn't need removed or added in?

    Some of these old stories are classics. A few others were posted by other users. And a few others were posted here at random.

    What I'm getting at here is that SR should probably get worked on a bit. Some of them don't seem to be the best for that category. I'm thinking that we should take a look.

    Support Support -
    {{Support}}
    Neutral Neutral -
    {{Neutral}}
    Oppose Oppose -
    {{Oppose}}
      Loading editor
    • Senjumaru Shutara
      Senjumaru Shutara removed this reply because:
      Then give 0 comments.
      05:49, May 11, 2015
      This reply has been removed
    • WHAT ABOUT

      UPDATING

      THE

      GOD

      DAMN

      PASTA

      OF

      THE

      FUCKING

      MONTH?

      http://spinpasta.wikia.com/wiki/Spinpasta_Wiki:Pasta_of_the_Month/Nominate

      >Nominations for November 2014

      NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND FUCKING FOURTEEN.

        Loading editor
    • TotemUxie wrote: WHAT ABOUT

      UPDATING

      THE

      GOD

      DAMN

      PASTA

      OF

      THE

      FUCKING

      MONTH?

      http://spinpasta.wikia.com/wiki/Spinpasta_Wiki:Pasta_of_the_Month/Nominate

      >Nominations for November 2014

      NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND FUCKING FOURTEEN.

      PotM is not that important. Please do not derail threads.

        Loading editor
    • I could get on PotM while you tackle the Suggested Reading. Support Support -

      Also, you should probably not have that many MLP darkfics in the category Classics.

        Loading editor
    • There was a discussion a while back on the definition of "Classics" that I don't know was ever fully agreed upon. I'm of the mind that it should be reserved for truly iconic works (regardless of quality) as a resource for people new to the community who won't necessarily get the wide references--the kinds of spin-offs that have had a measurable impact, that have notoriety outside just the Spinpasta Wiki. Unlike, say, Cheerilee's Garden, which is only really known here. I would even suggest that these legendary spinoffs (Squidward's Suicide, Ben Drowned, etc.) be added as articles to be included in the category even if already hosted on Creepypasta Wiki.

      As for Suggested Reading... do you have any specific examples on stories you don't feel are deserving of the tag, Shu (I'm not sure what to call you since the second name change)? I don't need fifty, but one or two might help me understand what you're talking about.

        Loading editor
    • Xelrog T. Apocalypse wrote: There was a discussion a while back on the definition of "Classics" that I don't know was ever fully agreed upon. I'm of the mind that it should be reserved for truly iconic works (regardless of quality) as a resource for people new to the community who won't necessarily get the wide references--the kinds of spin-offs that have had a measurable impact, that have notoriety outside just the Spinpasta Wiki. Unlike, say, Cheerilee's Garden, which is only really known here. I would even suggest that these legendary spinoffs (Squidward's Suicide, Ben Drowned, etc.) be added as articles to be included in the category even if already hosted on Creepypasta Wiki.

      As for Suggested Reading... do you have any specific examples on stories you don't feel are deserving of the tag, Shu (I'm not sure what to call you since the second name change)? I don't need fifty, but one or two might help me understand what you're talking about.

      Just call me Callie, like we all used to and still do.

      Anyhow, I'll probably produce a list of stories that should probably be removed for discussion of whether they should stay or not. Before I come up with it, however, I figured it should be discussed so that others could investigate it themselves and decide for or against.

      On the Classics category, that's pretty much what the category is for. Fatal and I decided to remake the category and put the stories that started off everything that makes this wiki here (e.g. BEN Drowned, Lil' Miss Rarity, Cherilee's Garden, etc.).

        Loading editor
    • Thank you! I think Cupcakes (Original) should stay on classics, though.

        Loading editor
    • CrazyWords wrote: Thank you! I think Cupcakes (Original) should stay on classics, though.

      Because that one is widely known and has impacted the entirety of the creepypasta community/lore outside this wiki. The other MLP pastas, haven't.

        Loading editor
    • Yea, like you said, Lil' Miss Rarity is famous on this site. Before I found this, I had never heard of it.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.